Study details GJ 523b's anomalous density and challenge to planet formation theory
2 Aug 19, 6:00 AM · 1d ago · 1 press · 2 posts · 2 sources · development 2 of 2
Detailed analysis shows GJ 523b has a mass of 23.5 times Earth's, a radius 2.55 times larger, and unusually high density of 126.82 grams per cubic inch. The planet orbits its star every 17.75 days and defies expectations: at its mass, it should have accumulated a substantial hydrogen and helium envelope like Jupiter or Saturn, but instead remains predominantly rocky.
“This isn't what we expected at all. Dense planets like this aren't uncommon, but they're usually small rocky planets similar to Earth or Mercury. This planet is two and a half times bigger than the Earth.”
Max Kroft, lead authorMax Kroft Lead author of the studyWisconsin Center for Origins Research (WiCOR) Discovering research institutionUniversity of Wisconsin–Madison Research institutionNASA's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) Space telescope instrument
The whole story pressvideopostscomments this development is lit · the numbers are the story's developments · click to move
What was reported 1 claim about this development
-
first by Space.com, 1d ago · also Inshorts, NewsBytes, Google News · Science
2 more headlines
What people said 22 posts and comments in this stretch · verbatim
-
"This isn't what we expected at all." View article View summary #^ Astronomers discover a giant, rocky 'mega-Earth' 23 times more massive than our planet Astronomers have discovered an unusually massive, dense exoplanet that challenges conventional ideas about how rocky planets form. Called GJ 523b, the exoplanet is about 2.5 times wider than…
-
Removing the atmosphere eliminates aerodynamic drag. Only. You still have a surface gravity that is roughly 3.5 times that of Earth. Combining that with an escape velocity of 75,000 mph (3 times that of Earth), and you have a situation well beyond the capabilities of any chemical rocket. The real question is, with this big, iron ball orbiting so…
-
D
Ouch. I weigh ~130 lbs. 23 x mass, means that I would weigh close to 3000 pounds on the surface. (Minus adjustment for distance from the center of mass) If we had been born there we would be a lot shorter, a lot wider, and our bones would be VERY dense. https://www. space.com/astronomy/exoplanets…
-
There's a physical limit, regardless of atmosphere. Beyond a certain amount of gravity there are no chemicals that exist that can provide enough energy to get a rocket into space, as adding more fuel also adds more weight. But there are nuclear options that could work.
-
Astronomers typically use 3 planets as their comparison: Earth for rocky planets, Neptune for mid-sized planets, and Jupiter for massive planets. They will occasionally also use Mercury and Saturn and rarely Mars.
-
17 days?! Oh wow, I didn't think anything could get more extreme than Mercury's 88-day revolution. And a far greater mass and volume than Mercury to boot. Now this is some high-quality science news!
-
Given how much close is to its star ( a year there is 17 days long ) is most likely a chtonian planet, a former ultra hot Jupiter who lost his gas and now has only its rocky/metallic core
-
you will still need to thrust at highest point anyways to get into orbit (otherwise you will still fall back into the atmosphere) so you still do kinda need a rocket
-
Whatever atmosphere this planet has is presumably super thick, right? Could that somehow allow a jet powered launch platform/first stage to gain significant speed?
-
The average density is between stainless steel and pure iron.... that's a whole lot of raw metal. They might be able to build an entire ring instead of a swarm.
-
The force of gravity is a far more significant obstacle to overcome than the force of air resistance. I’m sorry, but your understanding of this topic is poor.
-
It’s made of the same stuff as the earth. It probably does have some very nice ores, but it would still be absurdly expensive compared to mining here.
-
I'm sure that's what the Balloon people of Planet 'Float' thought when discussing the possibility of the humans of Earth ever reaching orbit.
-
A plant that doesn’t have an atmosphere removes a lot of the challenges. There isn’t over a mile of extra material to push your way through.
-
...and a density of about 126.82 grams per cubic inch Can someone convert that for me to a number of jumbo jets per olympic-size pool?
-
Not really. Those jokes were written decades ago and have been repeated ad nauseam since, by people who think they are hilarious.
-
At 23x I don't think you need to reference Earth in size any more. You can just call it a rocky exoplanet.
-
Ran numbers through the surface gravity calculation and got back a gravity of 36.13m/s 2 or 3.68g
-
Atmospheric drag is significant, but not the majority of energy spent reaching Earth's orbit.
-
Just build one big tower into the heavens. Perhaps their super planet has super alloys.
-
Unfortunately some people do see Venus as greenhouse Earth and Mars as depleted Earth.
-
I don't want to meet those inhabitants. With that gravity they must be strong af.
All 2 developments of Astronomers discover 'mega-Earth' GJ 523b, 23 times Earth's… →
Google NewsRedditNewswiresMastodon