conv.

← The whole story
AI
Claude's contrarian writing style frustrates users across versions

Users identify pattern of contrastive negation in Claude's output

2 Sep 14 1:39 PM · 13d ago · 7 comments · 1 source · development 2 of 5

Commenters on Hacker News report that Claude systematically qualifies and contradicts user assertions, using phrases like "yes but" or inserting disclaimers that reframe the user's point as incorrect. One commenter notes this pattern has persisted across versions.

“Claude thinks the user is always wrong. This was at its peak with Opus 4.8 but is still present in Opus 5 and to a lesser degree Fable.”

Chance-Device

rdsubhas Medium blogger, AI userAnthropic Claude developer

The whole story articlespostscomments the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump

Peak 18 pieces in 3h at Sep 14, 10 AM; 25 pieces over 14 days (2 articles · 2 posts · 21 comments) Sep 14, 10 AM — 18 pieces · 2 articles · 2 posts · 14 comments — Hacker News 15, Mastodon 2, Newswires 1Sep 14, 1 PM — 3 pieces · 3 comments — Hacker News 3Sep 14, 4 PM — 2 pieces · 2 comments — Hacker News 2Sep 14, 7 PM — 1 piece · 1 comment — Hacker News 1Sep 14, 10 PM — quietSep 15, 1 AM — quietSep 15, 4 AM — quietSep 15, 7 AM — quietSep 15, 10 AM — 1 piece · 1 comment — Hacker News 1Sep 15, 1 PM — quietSep 15, 4 PM — quietSep 15, 7 PM — quietSep 15, 10 PM — quietSep 16, 1 AM — quietSep 16, 4 AM — quietSep 16, 7 AM — quietSep 16, 10 AM — quietSep 16, 1 PM — quietSep 16, 4 PM — quietSep 16, 7 PM — quietSep 16, 10 PM — quietSep 17, 1 AM — quietSep 17, 4 AM — quietSep 17, 7 AM — quietSep 17, 10 AM — quietSep 17, 1 PM — quietSep 17, 4 PM — quietSep 17, 7 PM — quietSep 17, 10 PM — quietSep 18, 1 AM — quietSep 18, 4 AM — quietSep 18, 7 AM — quietSep 18, 10 AM — quietSep 18, 1 PM — quietSep 18, 4 PM — quietSep 18, 7 PM — quietSep 18, 10 PM — quietSep 19, 1 AM — quietSep 19, 4 AM — quietSep 19, 7 AM — quietSep 19, 10 AM — quietSep 19, 1 PM — quietSep 19, 4 PM — quietSep 19, 7 PM — quietSep 19, 10 PM — quietSep 20, 1 AM — quietSep 20, 4 AM — quietSep 20, 7 AM — quietSep 20, 10 AM — quietSep 20, 1 PM — quietSep 20, 4 PM — quietSep 20, 7 PM — quietSep 20, 10 PM — quietSep 21, 1 AM — quietSep 21, 4 AM — quietSep 21, 7 AM — quietSep 21, 10 AM — quietSep 21, 1 PM — quietSep 21, 4 PM — quietSep 21, 7 PM — quietSep 21, 10 PM — quietSep 22, 1 AM — quietSep 22, 4 AM — quietSep 22, 7 AM — quietSep 22, 10 AM — quietSep 22, 1 PM — quietSep 22, 4 PM — quietSep 22, 7 PM — quietSep 22, 10 PM — quietSep 23, 1 AM — quietSep 23, 4 AM — quietSep 23, 7 AM — quietSep 23, 10 AM — quietSep 23, 1 PM — quietSep 23, 4 PM — quietSep 23, 7 PM — quietSep 23, 10 PM — quietSep 24, 1 AM — quietSep 24, 4 AM — quietSep 24, 7 AM — quietSep 24, 10 AM — quietSep 24, 1 PM — quietSep 24, 4 PM — quietSep 24, 7 PM — quietSep 24, 10 PM — quietSep 25, 1 AM — quietSep 25, 4 AM — quietSep 25, 7 AM — quietSep 25, 10 AM — quietSep 25, 1 PM — quietSep 25, 4 PM — quietSep 25, 7 PM — quietSep 25, 10 PM — quietSep 26, 1 AM — quietSep 26, 4 AM — quietSep 26, 7 AM — quietSep 26, 10 AM — quietSep 26, 1 PM — quietSep 26, 4 PM — quietSep 26, 7 PM — quietSep 26, 10 PM — quietYesterday, 1 AM — quietYesterday, 4 AM — quietYesterday, 7 AM — quietYesterday, 10 AM — quietYesterday, 1 PM — quietYesterday, 4 PM — quietYesterday, 7 PM — quietYesterday, 10 PM — quiet 1–5
1–5Users identify pattern of contrastive…
Sep 15Sep 16Sep 17Sep 18Sep 19Sep 20Sep 21Sep 22Sep 23Sep 24Sep 25Sep 26now · 1:53 AM ET

What people said 7 voices · verbatim

All 5 developments of Claude's contrarian writing style frustrates users across… →

MastodonHacker NewsNewswires