Blog author defends letter's authenticity based on specific personal reference
5 Sep 15 3:48 PM · 12d ago · 5 comments · 1 source · development 5 of 5
Nemin, the blogger who published the letter, responds to skeptics by noting the emailer included a final line referencing a game Nemin is tangentially involved in, which he argues is beyond an LLM's capability to generate.
“there was one final line in the email that I cut off, that convinces me that it's was a specifically targeted and human-written mail.”
neminAnonymous ML engineer Self-described employee at frontier AI labnemin Blog author and publisherjfloren Lobsters commenterploum Lobsters commenter
The whole story postscomments the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
What people said 7 voices · best of 8 · verbatim
-
Look, I actually buy a lot of what the letter says, but it's also something I could have written myself with my passing knowledge of current AI tech. "They're hitting a wall" isn't exactly a groundbreaking proposition, and the letter offers nothing to back up the assertion. "AI is widely astroturfed" is certainly believable, but again, there's no…
-
> but it's also something I could have written myself with my passing knowledge of current AI tech. Yes, I touch on this in detail in the final section of the post. I think I approached the letter with a healthy amount of skepticism. > it might as well be an LLM prompt: You'll have to take my word for it, but there was one final line in the email…
-
All of this is predicated on the idea that being a late mover is a bad idea. That appears in a lot of management texts but more recently there's a lot more discussion of 'second move advantage'. It's much cheaper to adopt a mature technology than an early one. Take the web, for example. During the .com boom, every business decided it needed to…
-
> That’s also why they are so unethical and selling bad products: at worse, people die, there’s a scandal and the company pays a fine. But individuals have no responsibilty (just remember VW CEO during dieselgate). True professionals run the company into the ground with bad products, sell the company for peanuts to their immediately-previous…
-
Given that Symbian was also open, and strictly speaking was growing faster in the installation base than Android + iOS combined (in part because it fit weaker devices), and you mention it was flexible enough for that contract about Office to make any sense at all, I think it's Symbian that was the freshly burning platform. Doesn't matter in the…
-
> There's news about MS and Uber cutting back on their token quotas, because they've been spending so much money on them. I think all of Big Tech is shovelling bucketfuls of cash onto this every second, because they somehow still expect that to be cheaper than "being left out". I'm talking more about how all the AI in a lot of products are, at…
-
And you can even track and experiment now, without any sort of big buy in. I've always been a fan of this with vendors, too... even when I'm happy w/ a vendor I use, I keep loose contact with their competitors and occasionally do a free trial of a product or spend a bit of money on a small install just to keep up and keep options open.
All 5 developments of Anonymous ML Engineer Claims Frontier Labs Hitting Scaling… →
LobstersHacker News