Researchers caution against anthropomorphizing behavior while acknowledging emotional complexity
2 Sep 16 · 7d ago · 2 articles · 1 post · 2 sources · development 2 of 2
Scientists emphasize the need to avoid over-interpreting the whale's actions as human-like emotion while acknowledging the dramatic behavioral change mirrors responses in other socially complex mammals. Rebecca Dunlop from the University of Queensland notes such case studies risk anthropomorphizing, but the research presents a balanced argument about possible interpretations.
“It's pretty heartbreaking to watch this female making continuous contact with the deceased calf.”
Olaf MeyneckeAndrew Mulville Sea World Foundation observerOlaf Meynecke Marine ecologist, Griffith UniversityGriffith University and Sea World Foundation Research institutions
The whole story articlesposts the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
What was reported 2 claims about this development
-
first by Google News · Science, 7d ago · also Mirage News, Guardian Environment, EurekAlert!, The Guardian, CTV News, Live Science +4
11 more headlines
- Grieving Humpback Whale: Stillborn Calf Documented Mirage News · 7d ago
- Do whales grieve? Rare footage of humpback alongside stillborn calf suggests they might | Olaf Meynecke for the Conversation Guardian Environment · 7d ago
- Weeping whales: Stillborn humpback whale grieving documented Phys.org · 7d ago
- Do whales grieve? Rare footage of humpback alongside stillborn calf suggests they might The Guardian · 7d ago
- ‘Really sad’: Humpback whale documented apparently grieving stillborn calf cp24.com · 7d ago
- 'It is extremely rare to witness': Scientists record humpback whale mom grieving her stillborn calf in first-of-its-kind footage Live Science · 7d ago
- Humpback Whale Apparently Grieves Stillborn Calf in Rare Footage - ASHARQ AL-AWSAT English Google News · Science · 7d ago
- Humpback whale filmed ‘grieving’ stillborn calf in world-first footage Discover SWNS · 7d ago
- Whale mother spotted grieving stillborn calf Yahoo · 7d ago
- Humpback whale in wild observed greiving for stillborn calf swiowanewssource.com · 7d ago
- A Humpback Whale Mom Stayed With Her Stillborn Calf, Repeatedly Touching It and Staring Into Its Eyes. Was She Grieving? Smithsonian · 5d ago
-
first by ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 7d ago · also New Scientist, Geo News, inkl, The Canberra Times, WION, Times of India +2
9 more headlines
- Humpback whale mother with stillborn calf shows ‘grief-like’ behaviour New Scientist · 7d ago
- Mother Humpback Whale Appears to Grieve Stillborn Calf in ‘Heartbreaking’ and ‘Extremely Rare’ Footage People.com · 7d ago
- ‘Heartbreaking and extremely rare’: Mother humpback whale carries stillborn calf through the ocean; scientists explain the unusual behaviour timesofindia.indiatimes.com · 7d ago
- Humpback whale mother appears to grieve stillborn calf in rare underwater moment Geo News · 7d ago
- Mother whale’s heartbreaking moment with stillborn calf Inquirer.net · 7d ago
- Heartbreaking! Humpback whale mother filmed staying beside her stillborn calf in rare behaviour WION · 7d ago
- ‘Heartbreaking and extremely rare’: Mother humpback whale carries stillborn calf through the ocean; scien timesofindia.indiatimes.com · 6d ago
- Mother humpback whale carries stillborn calf through ocean in rare behaviour Times of India · 6d ago
- Humpback whale mother may have mourned her dead calf for days Science Daily · 1d ago
What people said 10 voices · best of 12 · verbatim
-
T
I would not be surprised. Sentience and emotions in animals are likely to be far more prevalent in all manner of animals than we humans like to believe. It would knock us off our pedestal. https://www. theguardian.com/environment/20 26/sep/17/do-whales-grieve-scientists-research-off-australias-gold-coast-suggests-they-might
-
Blows my mind that so many people just have this hardened internalized idea that we're somehow significantly different than any other animal.Sure, we've got them beat on language and planning, but we're currently in the process of being passed up on both those fronts by multi-dimensional arrays of floating point numbers sitting inside of sand. So…
-
R
How a humpback whale mother responds to her stillborn calf https://www. theguardian.com/environment/20 26/sep/17/do-whales-grieve-scientists-research-off-australias-gold-coast-suggests-they-might
-
That's two ethology stories on HN on one day. Interesting as news for nerds, but it is becoming relevant to more nerds than just me ;-) . (the other one is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49775579 "do birds have accents")
-
"She remained with it for several hours and possibly even days." Interesting article, but that comment veers into speculation. Speculation diminishes the value of a scientific article.
-
Ants don't walk in line over the stove. It may not be fear, but there is something hardwired that tells them not too, or they would be extinct long agoApplies to all living organisms
-
Unsurprisingly, mammals (not just humans) also fear death and are very distressed when being lead to slaughter and seeing their peers go down before them.
-
Any parent here who has known this loss can relate. Didn’t think I’d see this on HN but yeah this is heartbreaking.
-
> indicated an inherent, strong maternal attachment to the calfYeah, that's not grieving.
-
Applies to every living thing with a limbic system. So yes, that steak or chicken nuggets...
All 2 developments of Researchers document humpback whale grieving stillborn calf… →
NewswiresHacker NewsMastodonGoogle News