Gebru and Bender publish critique: claims don't withstand expert examination
1 Sep 22 7:04 AM · 1d ago · 1 article · 3 posts · 2 sources · development 1 of 1
Timnit Gebru and Emily Bender published an analysis arguing that all major AI industry claims from the summer—vulnerability detection, mathematical breakthroughs, and superintelligence warnings—collapse under scrutiny by domain experts. They argue the companies use anthropomorphizing language to evade accountability and that hacking incidents reflect OpenAI negligence, not rogue AI.
“Breathless claims about AGI and new capabilities fall apart pretty quickly under scrutiny.”
Timnit GebruTimnit Gebru AI researcher and co-authorEmily Bender AI researcher and co-authorOpenAI AI company making claimsAnthropic AI company making claimsJacob Coxon Anthropic engineer
The whole story articlesposts the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
What was reported 1 claim about this development
-
first by Mastodon, 1d ago · also MIT Tech Review, MIT Technology Review
What people said 24 voices · best of 27 · verbatim
-
E
From @ timnitGebru and me on what we should take from the 2026 summer of AI hype: https://www. technologyreview.com/2026/09/2 2/1144867/dont-be-fooled-summer-ai-hype/
-
It's a tough situation when your claim to fame is "On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big?" arguing models should be kept to < GPT-2 size because larger models will serve no purpose or function:Text generated by an LM is not grounded in communicative intent, any model of the world, or any model of the reader’s state…
-
G
It's so good to see this in the MIT Tech Review. Let's hope the message gets through. 🤞Big props to @ timnitGebru & @ emilymbender for putting such a fine point on things! "Instead of OpenAI being prosecuted for creating malware that hacked another company, press releases, news outlets, media personalities, and lawmakers refer to “rogue models”…
-
People aren't seeing the forest through the trees.While lots of developers, journalists, analysts, investors and influencers are bickering about AGI, goalposts, benchmarks, hypes and fears, entire markets are being transformed silently and steadily.I don't program anymore. (Massive change)I removed tons of technical debt (Massive change, lol)I am…
-
D
> Describing them as “superintelligence” or “rogue models” ascribes agency to products rather than to the companies building them. This framing markets these companies’ products as “superhuman” and, at the same time, helps the companies evade accountability for their actions. > Instead of OpenAI being prosecuted for creating malware that hacked…
-
If I run a port scanner / vulnerability fuzzer pointed at your network that churns for days and eventually cracks something and breaks your system, would you be upset with me, or my bash loops?What if you tried to sue me for damages and my defense was, "Your honor, this was a highly advanced AI gone rogue, I couldn't possibly be held negligent, no…
-
A must read about «AI» hype by @ emilymbender and @ timnitGebru . https://www. technologyreview.com/2026/09/2 2/1144867/dont-be-fooled-summer-ai-hype/ I found it particularly instructive to read the Leiden Declaration by mathematicians on «AI»: https:// leidendeclaration.ai/ I'd like to see a similar declaration on # hamradio and # AI . There's…
-
And if they'd discovered how to summon unicorns from Candy Gumdrop Mountain, we'd all be "OMG UNICORNS!"But no one has summoned a demon.No one has built an actual, independent, thinking-for-itself, sci-fi AI.They've built some very interesting tools that can be used for some very interesting, and sometimes useful, purposes. They then started…
-
In the MIT Technology Review , @ timnitGebru @ emilymbender puncture recent LLM hype and remind us to wait for experts to take a sober second look
-
That's not what the LLM hacking accidents have been like at all though. To improve the analogy, it would be like summoning a totally passive demon, giving it weapons and placing it next to a bank, place a small fence around it, and then command it to perform a totally safe "exercise" that is exactly like robbing a real bank.LLMs do not have…
-
B
Not for one second to let #AI & #DataCentres off the hook but there is a far greater, vastly more certain threat. #ClimateChange @fluidsguru.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gy
-
Your analogy assumes that no one ever has summoned demons before and that the demons would be predisposed to rob banks.A closer analogy to what's happening would be someone trains a monkey to steal jewellery and then is shocked when the monkey steals jewellery from their neighbors when they told it to steal from their own shop.Clearly all…
-
R
I also think we should be waiting for the experts' opinion - just not exclusively the opinions of those who have an existential fear of their expertise being made obsolete... Between big tech hype and criticism for its own sake, we should be able to adopt an intellectually honest position regarding the abilities and limitations of LLMs…
-
I think the pumped-up hype nicely coincides with some A.I. companies' desire to go public in the coming weeks or months.I see lots of fabricated news on the internet concerning LLMs. Like one that claims GPT-6 broke an Enigma enciphered message which has withstood decrypting for almost 80 years. And how this seasoned cryptographer stood in awe…
-
T
By me and @ emilymbender . "According to the AI industry, we should be more worried about a fictional machine god than about the climate catastrophe these data centers exacerbate, the asthma suffered by those living near them, the rising electricity bills of the public subsidizing them, or the water...[for] cooling them." https://www…
-
Is this meant to link to the article as opposed to a newsletter that mentions the article?Article link is:
-
D
#AI is rapidly reshaping health research, creating new opportunities to accelerate scientific discovery, strengthen health systems & improve health outcomes. 🆕 @who.int@bsky.brid.gy report provides recommendations to help ensure that AI-enabled health research is conducted responsibly & for the benefit of all: New WHO report calls for stron...
-
"Seriously, I don't get what sort of world these people are living in."Perhap it's a world that does not believe in "demons"Otherwise known by those seeking to escape it as "the real world"
-
D
@ timnitGebru and @ emilymbender puncture the latest AI hype, addressing everything from "hacking" to "math breakthroughs" to "superhuman" machines (and possibly break a record for scare quote usage along the way). https://www. technologyreview.com/2026/09/2 2/1144867/dont-be-fooled-summer-ai-hype/
-
Amusing juxtaposition:>Here’s why they say we must remain skeptical about AI hype.…22 nations have called for a new global body to oversee AI
-
O
Lol! I swear to DOG I DID NOT PLAGIARIZE THIS! You can check the time stamps! https://www. technologyreview.com/2026/09/2 2/1144867/dont-be-fooled-summer-ai-hype/
-
It's just a marketing stunt. I can't get Claude to align buttons properly most of the times, they're not going to conquer the world
-
Feels like the blockchain bubble all over again, just with more impressive demo reels. Still waiting for my LLM to write perfect code.
-
Thank you for the laugh, but I bet on the internet (and especially here) you surely would find people debating exactly that.
All 1 developments of Gebru and Bender: AI companies' summer hype collapses under… →
MastodonNewswiresHacker NewsGoogle NewsReddit