AI
Japanese scholars warn of 'knowledge appropriation' as AI trains on rare books
Academic researchers echo concerns about scholarly verification
2
Yesterday 8:38 AM
· 16h ago · 1 post · 1 source · development 2 of 2
Scholars respond that historical research requires access to original sources to verify credibility, and that feeding rare books to AI does not substitute for this requirement. They note that losing rare copies removes the ability to verify information at all.
x.com
“This is exactly right—especially for history papers, you must consult the original to ensure reliability. Feeding it to AI doesn't help, and if rare books are consumed, there's no way to verify anything.”
Hiroshi Hiranakaisseis1 (academic commenter)
@kotonoha_yakata Japanese commentator Hiroshi Hiranakaisseis1 Academic researcher
The whole story posts
the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
Peak 1 piece in one half hour at Sep 22, 10 PM; 2 pieces over 27 hours (2 posts)
Sep 22, 10:00 PM — quiet Sep 22, 10:30 PM — 1 piece · 1 post — X 1 Sep 22, 11:00 PM — quiet Sep 22, 11:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 12:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 12:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 1:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 1:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 2:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 2:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 3:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 3:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 4:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 4:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 5:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 5:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 6:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 6:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 7:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 7:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 8:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 8:30 AM — 1 piece · 1 post — Mastodon 1 Yesterday, 9:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 9:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 10:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 10:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 11:00 AM — quiet Yesterday, 11:30 AM — quiet Yesterday, 12:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 12:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 1:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 1:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 2:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 2:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 3:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 3:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 4:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 4:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 5:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 5:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 6:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 6:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 7:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 7:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 8:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 8:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 9:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 9:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 10:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 10:30 PM — quiet Yesterday, 11:00 PM — quiet Yesterday, 11:30 PM — quiet Today, 12:00 AM — quiet Today, 12:30 AM — quiet
1 2
yesterday 8 AM 4 PM now · 1:00 AM ET
What people said 1 voice · verbatim
K
八神夕歌(やがみ ゆうか)[T.Ishiyama]さん: 「どれだけ古書籍をAIに学習させたとしても、もとの紙の書籍に当たれなくなるのであれば、それは知識の簒奪に他ならない、というのが私の立場です。その中で、もしも孤本を自炊されてしまったら、どうするつもりなのでしょうか。それは恐ろしいことです。」 / X https:// x.com/kotonoha_yakata/status/2 102592108171543022 広中一成さん: 「これはおっしゃるとおりで、(特に歴史系)論文を書くにしても信頼性を担保するには原本に当たらなければならず、AIに食わせたところでしょうがないし、稀覯本食われたら確認のしようがないわね。」 / X https://…
All 2 developments of Japanese scholars warn of 'knowledge appropriation' as AI… →
Mastodon X