Coverage of the zinc-creep findings resurfaces online
1 Oct 30 2:55 PM · 8d ago · 1 article · 2 posts · 3 sources · development 1 of 1
Make Tech Easier's writeup of the report circulates via Google News, Hacker News, and Mastodon, bringing renewed attention to the 2024 findings nearly two years after publication.
“the first documented case of long-term zinc-induced creep failure despite a long history of usage over a century”
National Academies report, Consensus study report · hn ↗National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine Author of the consensus study reportNational Science Foundation (NSF) Operator of the Arecibo ObservatoryUniversity of Central Florida Facility manager that commissioned forensic investigation
The whole story articlesposts the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
Reported in the same hours no headline names this development itself — these 1 claim were published in its stretch
-
first by Make Tech Easier, 8d ago · also HN Frontpage
1 more headline
- Zinc creep in cable spelter sockets brought down the Arecibo telescope in 2020 HN Frontpage · 8d ago
What people said 12 voices · verbatim
-
The pictures on page 25 seem to show how this socket design fails. First because they didn't evenly distribute the wires in the socket (seriously??)... And second, the shear on the zinc from the compressed wire bundle is essentially a narrow rectangle in the direction of the cable with almost all the force concentrated in a narrow forward bit, not…
-
C
In today's @theoverspill: the Arecibo radio telescope collapsed in 2020 because of "zinc creep" in its 57-year-old cables, a new report has found. http:// theoverspill.blog/2026/11/03/h ackers-refrigerators-warmed-again-start-up-2776/
-
The forensic report on the failure of the cable sockets is at https://www.thorntontomasetti.com/sites/default/files/2022-0.... Unlike the linked article this includes detailed diagrams and discussion explaining how these sockets worked and how they failed.My attempt at a quick summary: the Arecibo instruments were held up by heavy steel cables…
-
J
One of the crossbeams has gone out askew on the treadle https:// maketecheasier.com/arecibo-zin c-creep-collapse/
-
I'd summarize it this way:With competent engineering and construction, the (failed at Arecibo) zinc socket cable anchors can be very reliable. Unfortunately, Arecibo's engineering was so-so, and the construction quality was half-assed.With annual inspections (by someone with a passable understanding of cable anchors) the problems at Arecibo could…
-
> Long-term low-current electroplasticity, induced by the electromagnetic waves from the Arecibo telescope itself, may have sped up the zinc creep, it says. The report recommends that NSF offer the remaining socket and cable sections for study by the research community.That seems a bit unlikely to me. As far as I know it was a radio telescope…
-
I did an apprenticeship in metalwork many..many years ago and I seem to recall the zinc is meant to be in compression. If a zinc plug pulled out, it was in shear. Sounds wrong to me. Vincenti: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_Engineers_Know_and_How_Th... Has a chapter on flush pop rivetting which discussed the loss of this kind of knowing.
-
The closest thing in my life to these zinc cable sockets are the zinc nubbins on the end of steel cables for bicycle gear and brake cables.And I've seen a worrying number of those fail after decades too. In cases I've seen, the fact that load is uneven between the strands usually seems to play a part - some always start to snap or pull out before…
-
In case you didn't see the video of collapse at the time (don't miss the drone footage which starts at 0:55):>Watch the Arecibo Observatory's catastrophic collapse!
-
There is a Practical Engineering video [1] discussing the failure. (Just saw that it is not a new one discussing the report, sorry)[1]
-
I think the "electromigration" part of this is a red herring. It seems perfectly plausible after reading this report that improper construction and low safety factors were the cause of the collapse.
-
Just as an odd aside... bicycle cables are made this way. The little fitting at the end of the cable is molded from zinc.
All 1 developments of National Academies report: zinc creep in cable sockets… →
Google NewsHacker NewsMastodonNewswires