Demoscene participants push back on AI autocomplete framing
2 Oct 31 3:22 PM · 11d ago · 5 comments · 1 source · development 2 of 2
Comments from HackerNews users active in or familiar with the demoscene highlight a fundamental tension: the scene values human constraint-solving and creative struggle, not automation. InvisibleUp argues the core appeal is mathematical prowess and puzzle-solving, not pretty pictures, and questions whether an AI solver undermines that ethos.
“I think you misunderstand the point of the demoscene. It's about mathematical prowess and the joy of puzzle-solving moreso than pretty pictures. Nobody in the scene wants a magic box that solves the puzzle for them.”
InvisibleUpdatavorous Developer / researcherHellMood Demoscener
The whole story articlespostscomments the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
What people said 5 voices · verbatim
-
> ... and the audience will ooo and aah because a human figured out how to do that stuff under constraint.Or because the audience appreciates the artists' emotion and creative effort embodied in what they're watching. The Razor1911 demo, released at Revision 2026, is a great example there - there's some neat effects but nothing groundbreaking, but…
-
The human side of the demo scene is what I think makes it appealing. Sharing and consuming. A fellow human did that! Coder-as-problem-solver-and-artist.For sure it’s intellectually interesting if AI can generate something novel within demoscene constraints (140 chars or extreme low res or a POKEY chip at 1MHz or whatever) … something humans maybe…
-
Misread this as Demosthenes at first.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DemosthenesWould be fun to see models trained on ancient figures that you could interact and chat with.Less fun to see models imitating human art, they’re not ready for that yet IMP because they’re too derivative and not creative in interesting ways in the way that humans are.
-
I think you misunderstand the point of the demoscene. It’s about mathematical prowess and the joy of puzzle-solving moreso than pretty pictures.Appropriate uses for AI could be to trace the history of demoscene effects, or to explain how a particular scene works so you can understand it better. Nobody in the scene wants a magic box that solves the…
-
Neat.To me, demoscene was about embracing new technology and using it to express yourself.It's enshrined now and so I find it to have served it's purpose. Look forward, not back.
All 2 developments of Developer trains language model on demoscene code to… →
Hacker NewsMastodonNewswires