Eastern European participants confirm Soviet texts were self-study tools, not classroom texts
5 Nov 2 11:17 AM · 6d ago · 4 comments · 1 source · development 5 of 9
Those who studied in Soviet systems clarify that textbooks were supplements to teacher instruction, not primary learning materials—explaining the gap between Western and Soviet pedagogy.
“I'm from Eastern Europe and studied a bit of math in undergrad and I referenced mostly from American books as everything else was just terrible to learn from.”
expedited123Andrey Kolmogorov Soviet mathematician; curriculum curatorTerence Tao Mathematician raised in the WestMagnus Carlsen Chess grandmaster raised in the West
The whole story articlespostscomments the bright band is this development · numbered dots are the others · click one to jump
What people said 4 voices · verbatim
-
Bulgarian/USSR Math Circles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Math_circle and problems they work on are in this book https://bookstore.ams.org/mcl-25Regular school you would solve problems in combinatorics, algebra and geometry together in class by offering small ideas or strategies then trying each one to point out what works and doesn't work. You do…
-
> At the same time before we go idealizing that system, what Western folks often see are the best of the best examples. Individuals who went to great schools, emigrated and excelled in the West. They may have gone to better schools, with better teachers, or had parents who cared more etc. They don't see a representative sample.That’s a bingo. Most…
-
I think the book is seen more of as a complementary thing to the teacher, not something you're expected to read and understand on your own (unless you're really smart). They give you the cold hard theory, exercises with little explanation and wish you off after that.I'm from Eastern Europe and studied a bit of math in undergrad and I referenced…
-
I had a copy of "Differential and Integral Calculus" by Piskunov that belonged to my father. The prologue said it was used in the curricula of technical schools in the USSR. I used to think about that fact a lot and tried to imagine what those Soviet technical schools would be like. There was a lot of content there that I did not see in any of the…
All 9 developments of Why Soviet math textbooks were harder than American ones →
Hacker NewsNewswires