conv.

All stories
AIRunning 4d

ChatGPT blocks direct requests to copy author styles

OpenAI restricts LLM's ability to mimic famous writers' voices, though competitors vary in approach.

5 items84 engagement53 comments Hacker NewsBluesky

Conversation activity · last 5 days peak 1/hr

Peak 1 item in one hour at Aug 8, 9 PM; 5 items over 5 days Aug 4, 1 PM — 1 itemAug 4, 2 PM — no itemsAug 4, 3 PM — no itemsAug 4, 4 PM — no itemsAug 4, 5 PM — no itemsAug 4, 6 PM — no itemsAug 4, 7 PM — no itemsAug 4, 8 PM — no itemsAug 4, 9 PM — no itemsAug 4, 10 PM — no itemsAug 4, 11 PM — no itemsAug 5, 12 AM — no itemsAug 5, 1 AM — no itemsAug 5, 2 AM — no itemsAug 5, 3 AM — no itemsAug 5, 4 AM — no itemsAug 5, 5 AM — no itemsAug 5, 6 AM — no itemsAug 5, 7 AM — no itemsAug 5, 8 AM — no itemsAug 5, 9 AM — no itemsAug 5, 10 AM — no itemsAug 5, 11 AM — no itemsAug 5, 12 PM — no itemsAug 5, 1 PM — no itemsAug 5, 2 PM — no itemsAug 5, 3 PM — no itemsAug 5, 4 PM — no itemsAug 5, 5 PM — no itemsAug 5, 6 PM — no itemsAug 5, 7 PM — no itemsAug 5, 8 PM — no itemsAug 5, 9 PM — no itemsAug 5, 10 PM — no itemsAug 5, 11 PM — no itemsAug 6, 12 AM — no itemsAug 6, 1 AM — no itemsAug 6, 2 AM — no itemsAug 6, 3 AM — no itemsAug 6, 4 AM — no itemsAug 6, 5 AM — no itemsAug 6, 6 AM — no itemsAug 6, 7 AM — no itemsAug 6, 8 AM — no itemsAug 6, 9 AM — no itemsAug 6, 10 AM — no itemsAug 6, 11 AM — no itemsAug 6, 12 PM — no itemsAug 6, 1 PM — no itemsAug 6, 2 PM — no itemsAug 6, 3 PM — no itemsAug 6, 4 PM — no itemsAug 6, 5 PM — no itemsAug 6, 6 PM — no itemsAug 6, 7 PM — no itemsAug 6, 8 PM — no itemsAug 6, 9 PM — no itemsAug 6, 10 PM — no itemsAug 6, 11 PM — no itemsAug 7, 12 AM — no itemsAug 7, 1 AM — no itemsAug 7, 2 AM — no itemsAug 7, 3 AM — no itemsAug 7, 4 AM — no itemsAug 7, 5 AM — no itemsAug 7, 6 AM — no itemsAug 7, 7 AM — no itemsAug 7, 8 AM — no itemsAug 7, 9 AM — no itemsAug 7, 10 AM — no itemsAug 7, 11 AM — no itemsAug 7, 12 PM — no itemsAug 7, 1 PM — no itemsAug 7, 2 PM — no itemsAug 7, 3 PM — 1 itemAug 7, 4 PM — no itemsAug 7, 5 PM — no itemsAug 7, 6 PM — no itemsAug 7, 7 PM — no itemsAug 7, 8 PM — no itemsAug 7, 9 PM — no itemsAug 7, 10 PM — no itemsAug 7, 11 PM — no itemsAug 8, 12 AM — no itemsAug 8, 1 AM — no itemsAug 8, 2 AM — no itemsAug 8, 3 AM — no itemsAug 8, 4 AM — no itemsAug 8, 5 AM — no itemsAug 8, 6 AM — no itemsAug 8, 7 AM — no itemsAug 8, 8 AM — no itemsAug 8, 9 AM — no itemsAug 8, 10 AM — no itemsAug 8, 11 AM — no itemsAug 8, 12 PM — no itemsAug 8, 1 PM — no itemsAug 8, 2 PM — no itemsAug 8, 3 PM — no itemsAug 8, 4 PM — no itemsAug 8, 5 PM — no itemsAug 8, 6 PM — no itemsAug 8, 7 PM — no itemsAug 8, 8 PM — no itemsAug 8, 9 PM — 1 itemAug 8, 10 PM — 1 itemAug 8, 11 PM — no itemsAug 9, 12 AM — no itemsAug 9, 1 AM — no itemsAug 9, 2 AM — no itemsAug 9, 3 AM — no itemsAug 9, 4 AM — no itemsAug 9, 5 AM — 1 itemAug 9, 6 AM — no itemsAug 9, 7 AM — no itemsAug 9, 8 AM — no itemsAug 9, 9 AM — no itemsAug 9, 10 AM — no itemsAug 9, 11 AM — no itemsAug 9, 12 PM — no itemsAug 9, 1 PM — no itemsAug 9, 2 PM — no itemsAug 9, 3 PM — no itemsAug 9, 4 PM — no itemsAug 9, 5 PM — no itemsAug 9, 6 PM — no itemsAug 9, 7 PM — no itemsAug 9, 8 PM — no items 1 item · 9 PM
Aug 5Aug 6Aug 7Aug 8Aug 9

Summary, timeline and people extracted by Claude from 5 items across 2 sources · 8h ago. Quotes are verbatim.

OpenAI has implemented restrictions on ChatGPT to prevent users from directly requesting the system copy or mimic specific authors' writing styles, aligning with ethical guidelines from the Authors Guild. The move comes after high-profile incidents like author Lena McDonald facing criticism for AI-generated content explicitly mimicking another writer's style, and reflects broader concerns about copyright and unfair competition, though other LLMs (Gemini, Claude, Copilot) vary in how strictly they enforce such restrictions.

  • OpenAI has restricted ChatGPT from directly copying or mimicking specific authors' writing styles, responding to ethical and legal concerns around copyright.
  • The Authors Guild published best practices warning against using AI to mimic fellow writers' voices in ways that harm their work or enable profit.
  • Other major LLMs handle style-imitation requests inconsistently: Gemini complies; Perplexity refuses; Claude and Copilot comply with qualifications.
  • Some ChatGPT users report frustration with the new restrictions, finding them difficult to work around for legitimate creative purposes.

How it unfolded

  1. Reaction User frustration reported

    Reddit user Dazzling-Major-5620 expresses difficulty adapting to ChatGPT's new restrictions on style-specific content generation.

  2. Reaction Community response on social media

    Discussion emerges on Bluesky and Hacker News about ChatGPT's new restrictions on style imitation.

  3. 5 weeks quiet
  4. Event ChatGPT implements style-blocking

    OpenAI updates ChatGPT to start blocking direct requests to copy or mimic specific authors' styles, capturing only broader qualities instead.

  5. 30 weeks quiet
  6. Report OpenAI model spec published

    OpenAI's extensive model spec published in December does not include clearly stated prohibitions against replicating copyrighted material or mimicking style in written responses.

  7. 22 weeks quiet
  8. Event Lena McDonald style-copy incident

    Author Lena McDonald faced widespread criticism when her book included an AI-generated response stating 'I've rewritten the passage to align more with [fellow genre author] J. Bree's style…'

What people are saying verbatim

“respect your fellow authors and do not use generative AI to purposely copy or mimic the unique styles, voices, or other distinctive attributes of other writers' works in ways that harm the value of their works or attempt to profit from them.”

Authors Guild · Ars Technica / Authors Guild best practices document

“I've rewritten the passage to align more with [fellow genre author] J. Bree's style…”

AI system used by Lena McDonald · Ars Technica · Jun 30

“is designed to decline requests that ask for an image in the style of a living artist.”

OpenAI, DALL·E 3 policy description · Ars Technica

“Now Ms. GPT says she can't generate content in the style of specific authors. My prompts were soooo specific and I got exactly what I wanted out of them… I have no idea how to get around this other than maybe feed it prose I already edited that's technically mine?”

Dazzling-Major-5620, ChatGPT user · Reddit