SparrowMap launches crowdsourced tracking of government vehicles
New tool lets volunteers use spare phones to record license plates of police and official cars on public roads.
What to know
- SparrowMap enables volunteers to deploy low-cost cameras that automatically detect and record license plates of government vehicles, while destroying all footage of private citizens on-device before transmission.
- The platform positions itself as a 'sousveillance' transparency tool against commercial surveillance networks like Flock, with detection running locally on volunteers' devices to prevent video interception.
- Hacker News discussion splits between supporters viewing it as legitimate government accountability and skeptics questioning its practical purpose and security practices.
The dispute Whether crowdsourced tracking of government vehicles constitutes legitimate accountability or represents a half-baked surveillance project without concrete purpose. · positions read across 10 posts and comments
Government vehicles should be tracked as accountability tool; public servants deserve public scrutiny.
-
“It's a very important tool to figure out which people in positions of authority are coordinating for authoritarian purposes or just plain old corruption.”
Teever · Hacker News
The project is poorly designed and lacks clear actionable purpose beyond data collection.
-
“If you capture TBs of video footage and nobody sees it, what's the point? Are you going to start sending harassing posts to employees with footage of the car driving by your camera?”
dylan604 · Hacker News
Security and trust concerns require verification of installation binaries and open-source review.
-
“Are the .exe to install a always on computer as part of a open source repo I can verify with a hash? Otherwise I am not going to trust it.”
nickandbro · Hacker News
SparrowMap creators Project developers
The record 1 articles and posts · last 30 days
What people are saying 9 voices from 1 site · best of 10 · verbatim
- How will the recorded government vehicle data actually be used and by whom?
- Are the installation binaries open-source verifiable and auditable for security?
- Aug 13
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/His_Eye_Is_on_the_Sparrowhttps://en.wikisource.org/wiki/His_Eye_Is_on_the_Sparrow I sing because I’m happy, I sing because I’m free, For His eye is on the sparrow, And I know He watches me.
-
Are the .exe to install a always on computer as part of a open source repo I can verify with a hash? Otherwise I am not going to trust it.
-
All public servants should have all their info publicly available, some safety measures can be put like some delays or similar, but as the name implies, public servant! Police for example should be watched and they should feel they are actively being watched by the public, also their badge numbers should be available on these maps so you just…
-
The term you're looking for is sousveillance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SousveillanceIt's a very important tool to figure out which people in positions of authority are coordinating for authoritarian purposes or just plain old corruption.I'm instantly suspicious of anyone in government who is critical of this idea.What are they hiding?
-
To the wonderful creators, who will presumably find this thread: did you know that sparrows had at least two full millenia of being associated with lust and depravity, rather than the connotation used here and in the final book of ISOIAF (Game Of Thrones)? Well... now you do! I beg of you to fit an easter egg to this effect somwhere in this site…
-
How would the video captured from those cameras be used? These people are already driving on the same streets you and I do, so how would they not also be in the Flock footage? If you capture TBs of video footage and nobody sees it, what's the point? Are you going to start sending harassing posts to employees with footage of the car driving by your…
-
It sure would be interesting if suddenly all of the Flock employees coming to work were being constantly watched by a network of crowdfunded private cameras. Might drive home the point of invasion of privacy if its someone other than them watching...them. Or if all of the neighbors of the CEO of Flock suddenly joined some service like this so that…
-
I keep saying if it's legal for Flock to make Flock it's legal for anyone else to make Flock.
-
Fun fact: in some municipalities you can FOIA for the GPS records of police vehicles. Here's Chicago Police's. They removed 0-15mph for, erm, privacy reasons.... but it's not the worst.Have a glance: