ICE mistakenly detains, injures US citizen in Evanston, Illinois
Federal agents hunting a fugitive detained the wrong man, left him bloodied on a suburban Chicago street, then drove off before DHS confirmed the mistake days later.
Part of a larger narrative
ICE Shooting in Austin
- ICE Officer Who Shot Venezuelan Man in Austin Had No Body Camera
- ICE mistakenly detains, injures US citizen in Evanston, Illinoisyou are here
- Judge blocks deportation of Venezuelan man shot by ICE; doctor says he needs spinal surgery
What to know
- ICE agents conducting a fugitive investigation mistook a U.S. citizen for their target in Evanston, restrained him, and left him injured on the ground before driving off.
- DHS did not confirm the mistaken-identity account until Wednesday, three days after the Sunday incident, in response to The Hill's inquiry.
- Evanston police are still investigating, collecting body-camera footage and witness video; the agents involved have not been publicly identified.
- The incident has amplified broader criticism of ICE's tactics during the Trump administration's immigration crackdown, with online commentary linking it to prior reports of citizens being targeted in Minneapolis.
The dispute Whether the incident reflects a systemic pattern of racially targeted ICE tactics or an isolated mistaken-identity error, as officially characterized by DHS and local police. · positions read across 6 posts and comments
This is part of a broader ICE pattern of indiscriminate, race-driven targeting regardless of citizenship.
-
“In Minneapolis, ICE routinely targeted US citizens, didn't give a damn about immigration status when they harassed and detained people, and they told us as much.”
inthehands · Mastodon ↗
Official statements downplaying risk to citizens are contradicted by this incident.
-
“But Tom Homan said U.S. citizens have nothing to fear from ICE…”
jaykuo · Mastodon ↗
Schenita Stewart Evanston Police ChiefDaniel Biss Mayor of Evanston
Tom Homan Federal immigration enforcement official
Department of Homeland Security Federal agency overseeing ICEUnnamed detained man U.S. citizen injured by ICE
How it unfolded 5 developments, newest first · click a bar or a number to jump articlesvideosposts
-
5
AP reporting adds detail: man left 'bloodied' after arrest attempt
Associated Press coverage, picked up by the Philadelphia Inquirer and Japan Today, described the citizen as left bloodied and injured on the roadside after agents mistook him for a fugitive and tried to arrest him.
-
2 outlets U.S. citizen injured in Illinois after ICE agents mistook him for fugitive, tried to arrest him
first by Japan Today, 5h ago · also Philadelphia Inquirer
-
1 outlet US citizen injured in Illinois after ICE agents mistook him for fugitive, tried to arrest him
first by Associated Press, 12h ago
-
P
@cnn.com reports ICE assault of another US citizen in a Chicago suburb, leaving him on the ground w/ injuries. He was found on the ground by police in Evanston after officers were dispatched around 9:49 a.m. Evanston Police Department are investigating.
1 more of the top 2 · 2 posts in this stretch
-
S
https:// apnews.com/article/chicago-ill inois-ice-immigration-agents-evanston-police-2e07d80e8d96685489e914880a40e4d5?utm_source=app&utm_medium=iOS_share&utm_campaign=copy_link
-
-
4
Detained man's own words surface in new CNN segment
CNN aired footage including the man's reaction during the confrontation, as police reiterated agents were dispatched to Evanston around 9:49 a.m. and left him on the ground.
“I'm a f**king US citizen…”
— the detained man -
3
DHS confirms mistaken-identity incident to The Hill
A DHS spokesperson told The Hill on Wednesday that ICE officers in Evanston found a man they mistook for a fugitive during the operation, corroborating local police accounts of the mistaken detention.
-
1 outlet first by The Hill, 12h ago · read ↗
-
-
2
NBC News airs eyewitness footage of the takedown
NBC News published video and an eyewitness account describing agents putting the man on the ground after he refused to hand over identification, then leaving the scene.
“The ICE officers eventually get in the black SUV and drive off, leaving the man on the ground. The bystanders begin trying to help the man and call Evanston police.”
— dougiec3, Mastodon user · source -
In Minneapolis, ICE routinely targeted US citizens, didn't give a damn about immigration status when they harassed and detained people, and they told us as much. They bragged about the money they were getting per person brought in, “by the head,” like cattle. It was all about race. They knew it, we knew it, they knew we knew it. Article…
2 more of the top 3 · 3 posts in this stretch
-
D
" The ICE officers eventually get in the black SUV and drive off, leaving the man on the ground. The bystanders begin trying to help the man and call Evanston police." https://www. nbcnews.com/video/federal-agen ts-mistakenly-target-u-s-citizen-during-operation-outside-chicago-270305861852 # ICE # Fascism # Nazis # USA
-
J
But Tom Homan said U.S. citizens have nothing to fear from ICE… Story: https:// evanstonnow.com/federal-agents -detained-u-s-citizen-sunday-morning/
-
- 1 day quiet
-
1
Evanston police and mayor detail agents' account of the encounter
EPD said an agent identified himself as conducting a fugitive investigation, said the man 'resisted detention' after refusing ID, and released him after learning he was a citizen; Mayor Daniel Biss said he was 'briefly detained and then released' and treated for minor injuries.
“detained for fingerprinting, and resisted detention…”
— Evanston Police Department statement -
first by Evanston Now, 2d ago
-
G
“Federal (ICE) agents briefly detained and released a U.S. citizen on Sunday morning in Evanston. Officers were dispatched after an “unknown caller reported hearing two males arguing and someone stating that an individual would be taken into custody.” Police said they responded to an adult male on the ground “with several people assisting him.”…
-
-
background
ICE agents detain and injure Evanston man mistaken for fugitive — Responding to a report of two men arguing, Evanston police found an adult male on the ground with head, neck and tooth injuries after individuals believed to be ICE agents attempted to take him into custody near Howard Street and Dodge Avenue.
Also covered reported alongside — the timeline has no entry for these yet
-
first by CNN, 12h ago · also The New York Times
2 more headlines
- ‘I’m a f**king US citizen’: Man left injured after ICE mistakenly detained him, officials say CNN · 12h ago
- ICE Mistakenly Detains U.S. Citizen in Chicago Area, Leaving Him Injured The New York Times · 12h ago
and 2 smaller pieces