Trump's $4B Israel Aid Cut Claim Called Rebranding, Not a Cut
Trump announced ending $4 billion in aid to Israel on Election Day, but experts say the money will likely just be renamed and moved into the defense budget.
What to know
- Trump announced on Fox & Friends that the US would end a $4 billion payment to Israel at year's end, timed to Election Day.
- Weapons trade analysts say the move is largely symbolic: the aid will likely be renamed as 'joint defense partnerships' and folded into the defense budget rather than eliminated.
- Trump did not clarify whether the $4 billion referred to military aid or cash, and said US weapons sales to Israel would continue regardless.
- Congress and Netanyahu had already been moving toward reframing Israel aid as a legally mandated defense-industrial partnership, with a related bill pending in the Senate after the midterms.
“[Israel is] fine with it because they've become a very successful country. They don't need it. And we won't be paying anymore…we won't be paying Israel. We'll help Israel if they need it.”
Donald Trump, US President · Fox & Friends, via Mother Jones ↗ · Nov 2
Donald Trump US President
Benjamin Netanyahu Israeli Prime MinisterMatt Duss Center for International Policy analyst, former Bernie Sanders aide
How it unfolded 2 developments, newest first · click a bar or a number to jump articlesposts
-
2
Experts say aid will be repackaged, not eliminated
Matt Duss of the Center for International Policy said the plan is to rename and reprogram the aid as 'joint defense partnerships' tucked into the defense budget, meaning taxpayers will likely pay more with less oversight, not less.
“American taxpayers will almost certainly be paying more money, but with even less congressional oversight.”
— Matt Duss -
On the morning of Election Day, Donald Trump went on Fox & Friends to deliver a surprise announcement: The United States, he said, would be cutting off $4 billion in aid to Israel at the end of the year. Unfortunately, this doesn't mean your tax dollars will no longer fund Israeli wars.
1 more of the top 2 · 2 posts in this stretch
-
Trump said he’s cutting off $4 billion in aid to Israel—to score last-minute rhetorical points over Abdul El-Sayed. It's too little, too late, and not entirely true.
-
-
1
Trump announces $4 billion cut to Israel aid on Fox & Friends
On Election Day morning, Trump told Fox & Friends the US would stop a $4 billion payment to Israel at the end of the year, saying Israel 'doesn't need it' while insisting US weapons sales to Israel would continue.
“We have a helper, and it's Israel because, you know, we are the big, they are the small.”
— Donald Trump -
first by Mother Jones, 4d ago
-
-
background
Congress weighs reframing Israel aid as defense partnership — Lawmakers were already considering phasing out direct financial aid to Israel and instead legally mandating it as a defense industrial partnership; a Senate bill would establish a cooperative program with Israel's Ministry of Defense on countering unmanned systems, to be debated after the midterms.
-
background
US and Israel begin talks on new joint weapons pact — Negotiations began on a new memorandum of understanding for joint US-Israeli weapons development, ahead of the expiration of the current memorandum in 2028.
-
background
Netanyahu proposes tapering off direct US military aid — Amid rising US public opposition to Israel, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu suggested Israel should 'taper off' direct US military assistance over the following decade, proposing a joint weapons research and development model in its place.